Commentary: Deere did ‘holy work’ for all Native Americans
The Rev. Alvin Deer
July 7, 2005
A UMNS Commentary
By the Rev. Alvin Deer*
When the Rev. Kenneth
Deere lost his bout with cancer on June 23, I lost a friend. On June 27,
we celebrated his life at his home church of Salt Creek, a place he
During his 27 years of
serving in the Washington-based United Methodist Commission on Religion
and Race, Kenneth would long for the simpler life of Salt Creek, in
rural Holdenville, Oklahoma. It was a place he went many times to
re-center himself before returning to the battle for equality and
dignity for all Native Americans.
Kenneth Deere was a
veteran. Not only did he serve honorably in the U.S. Marine Corps, but
he served on other front lines not that familiar to Americans.
He was in Washington
when the American Indian Movement took over the Bureau of Indian Affairs
in 1972, and he offered assistance as clergy during the siege at
Wounded Knee in 1973. These
events happened at the height of the civil rights movement for Native
Americans. Wounded Knee was the site of an 1890 Army massacre in
South Dakota against a peaceful Lakota band led by Chief Bigfoot.
The 1973 siege, as well as the Bureau of Indian Affairs
takeover, were symbolic stands against corruption in the
bureau and police brutality.
Kenneth lived with
knowing that when he was born in 1936, his parents had been U.S.
citizens for only 12 years, even though they were born in America.
American Indians were not granted the rights of citizenship until 1924.
And it wasn’t until 1980 that the United Methodist Church granted voting
rights to delegates from Deere’s home conference, the Oklahoma Indian
One of the last fronts
on which Kenneth fought was the issue of Native American symbols being
used as sports mascots. For the last few years, he would travel to
Cleveland for opening day of the baseball season, attend a Native
American conference and then picket Jacobs Field, where the Cleveland
Indians baseball team plays.
supporters of the “Chief Wahoo” mascot called Kenneth and the other
picketing Native Americans every name in the book. The Indians whom the
fans loved were pretend Indians, who conjured up every stereotype about
Native Americans they could think of to the delight of Cleveland Indians
The Rev. Kenneth J. Deere
Kenneth was behind the
passing of a resolution to denounce Native American sports mascots at
the 2004 General Conference, the United Methodist Church’s top
legislative gathering, in Pittsburgh. Delegates from around the world
rejected the use of Native American names and symbols for sport teams,
calling the practice dehumanizing and a blatant expression of racism.
They also noted that their denomination has been one of many faith
groups calling for respect for Native American legacies and traditions.
The resolution, approved 842-10, reaffirmed the church’s commitment to
“participate actively in the continued struggle of building the true
community of God, where reconciliation comes together with justice and
The General Conference
called upon all churchwide agencies, annual conferences and other United
Methodist-related entities to hold meetings and events only in cities
that do not sponsor sport teams using Native American names and symbols.
After choosing an event location, the organization should state the
denomination’s position regarding Native American names.
My friend Ken died
without seeing either society or the United Methodist Church take this
work seriously. Recently, United Methodist-related McMurry University,
in the former wild West town of Abilene, Texas, rejected changing its
mascot name from the “Indians.”
I asked the question at
Ken’s funeral: Is social justice holy work? Conservative and
ultra-conservative circles, both political and religious, see social
justice as secular and not godly. The word we use in the church to
describe the work Kenneth Deere did is “advocate.” He was a true
advocate for all ethnic people.
A funny thing is that
the word “advocate” is also a word used for the Holy Spirit. Some
people might say there was nothing holy about Ken, but he did some holy
work. Psalm 82:3 says: “Defend the poor and fatherless; do justice to
the afflicted and needy.” We forget that sometimes in the church. But
the very heart of God is with the least, the last and the lost. Social
justice is holy work.
Kenneth Deere once told
a colleague a lesson he learned about red ants. He was told by an uncle
to stand on an ant hill and wait. It wasn’t long before the ants got
his attention. How Kenneth accomplished his work many times was the work
of a red ant. Those tiny little red ants can bring a sting that will
make someone a 1,000 times larger move. This was how Ken got the church
to move. His sting, though small in a church of 10 million, was enough
to get the attention of anyone who stood on his ant hill.
We will miss Ken Deere. The church will miss his sting.
*Deer is executive director of the Native American International Caucus, a United Methodist advocacy organization.
News media contact: Tim Tanton, Nashville, Tenn., (615) 742-5470 or firstname.lastname@example.org.
Kenneth Deere, Native American leader, dies at age 69
Church caucus protests Indian mascots
Task force acts to sharpen focus on native spirituality
General Commission on Religion and Race
Oklahoma Indian Missionary Conference