|Task force seeks ways to increase Hispanic clergy|
The Rev. Francisco Cañas addresses a task force comprising
members of the United Methodist Board of Higher Education and Ministry
and the denomination's National Plan for Hispanic/Latino Ministry. UMNS
photos by Linda Green.
By Linda Green*
Dec. 13, 2007 | NASHVILLE, Tenn. (UMNS)
For some Hispanic men and women, life circumstances make it difficult
to get the education required by The United Methodist Church to respond
to God's call to ordained ministry.
A task force of members of the denomination's National Plan for
Hispanic/Latino Ministry and the United Methodist Board of Higher
Education and Ministry spent Dec. 11 discussing how to develop
Hispanic/Latino pastoral leadership and consider alternatives to
education for ordained ministry.
Bishop Minerva Carcaño of Phoenix, task force chairwoman, noted that
some Hispanics do not have access to the denomination's educational
processes and institutional systems for ordination.
"We feel that God is giving us an opportunity to respond by walking with
them and finding ways to enable them to respond to their call," she
said. "The church needs them -- not only the Hispanic/Latino community
but the whole church because of their spirit, their experience of God
and the witness they bring to the table."
Seminaries require an undergraduate degree, but only about half of
Hispanic youth graduate from high school, and 9 or 10 percent go to
college. "So the group that could go to seminary diminishes
exponentially," Carcaño said.
According to the Rev. Francisco Cañas, coordinator of the Hispanic Plan,
the development of new Hispanic pastoral leaders is critical because 40
percent of the leadership serving the 733 Hispanic/Latino ministries
that currently exist has retired, while 60 percent serve local
congregations and the remainder are local pastors.
"That means we have few ordained clergy in the United Methodist context for Hispanic/Latino ministry," he said.
The church has 630 Hispanic clergy members, according to the 2006
racial/ethnic clergy membership summary of the General Council on
Finance and Administration.
'This is about leadership'
The Hispanic/Latino Education Task Force was formed following a
self-assessment by the 12-year-old National Plan for Hispanic/Latino
Ministry. One issue that surfaced in the assessment was the need to do a
more effective job of preparing Hispanic/Latinos for pastoral ministry.
"That had to be a priority," Carcaño said. “We can't develop the
congregations, we can't form those faith communities, and we can't
disciple persons without the right leadership. This is about that
leadership for the church."
The Rev. Saul Espino and Bishop Minerva Carcaño participate in the Dec. 11 meeting.
Latinos who arrive in the United States are not simply Roman Catholic.
Many have been influenced by the evangelical movement that has spread
across Latin America and the Caribbean.
"We have tremendous opportunities for reaching out and partnering with
people who already know Christ, who already have a faith commitment and
are seeking a church that is responsive to that — a church that is
grounded in community, that cares about the world, that cares about our
society," Carcaño said. "Social holiness is very much of the spirit of
Latinos and Hispanics. It is part of the way we look at life and our
faith. That is who we are as United Methodists and so we have a great
opportunity to be about disciple-making and disciple-empowering for the
transformation of the world."
Since the plan was established, the focus has been on developing lay
leadership in Hispanic churches. "A lot of work has gone into that, but
when we did the assessment, we realized that we hadn't put that kind of
effort into a pastoral leadership component," said Helene
Slessarev-Jamir, professor of urban ministries at Claremont (Calif.)
School of Theology.
Barriers to ministry
Slessarev-Jamir told the task force that the assessment, which
involved visiting 10 annual conferences and interviewing another six by
phone, indicated that those participating in lay leadership development
modules were interested in pastoral leadership but faced barriers to
making a transition.
Hispanic lay members said the denominational system allows students with
more traditional backgrounds to get through but not those who come from
nontraditional educational backgrounds – for example, students who
don’t have a high school diploma or undergraduate degree.
"In a sense, ultimately we have a structure that is not welcoming, that
does not facilitate their entry into doing what they have a passion for.
We have not created the vehicles to allow them to fully come to the
table," Slessarev-Jamir said.
To address these problems, conversations with the United Methodist Board
of Higher Education and Ministry and annual conferences and their
boards of ordained ministry are planned.
The task force wants to engage the Board of Higher Education and
Ministry, seminaries and other academic institutions in a dialogue
concerning support of partnerships that would accelerate completion of
bachelor degrees in areas related to pastoral ministry and graduate
The task force also wants the agency, annual conferences and seminaries
to take a critical look at the Course of Study programs, which are used
by Hispanics, young people and others for pastoral ministry and to
explore alternative criteria for ordination in The United Methodist
"The course of study is a 'treasure' in our system, but we need to
improve the quality of (the) course of studies. That is what we are
looking for," Cañas said.
Annual conference option
Most Hispanics in ministry are local pastors, and a few become full ordained elders, Slessarev-Jamir said.
There is a disciplinary process to make the path to ordination shorter
if annual conferences would choose to make it so, according to the Rev.
Mary Ann Moman, the staff executive over the Division of Ordained
Ministry of the Board of Higher Education and Ministry.
"One of the questions related to that is our value of an educated clergy and what that means in this time," she said.
The Rev. Aquiles Martinez talks about Hispanic/Latino pastoral leadership challenges.
Most United Methodist clergy go through a seminary degree program, but the denomination’s Book of Discipline also offers other ways to fulfill that educational requirement.
"It is important for us as a denomination to look at how we can
implement that other way in some creative ways for the church, not to
lower our standards, but how we can use what we have as process to
increase the number of pastors in a variety of communities," she said.
The Rev. Aquiles Martinez, a professor at Reinhardt College, Waleska,
Ga., said the task force "shouldn't at this point, at this juncture,
rely on what higher education can do and will do for our Hispanic
students. Because in the structure, what you have is a gap between
reality and the institution."
The priority is providing Hispanic/Latino people with opportunities to go to college, he said.
"The institution marginalizes them and objectifies them. That is not
justice. The United Methodist Board of Higher Education and Ministry
needs to be more relevant in that respect. They need to hear our voices
and hear them loudly if we are going to scratch where it itches."
Task force members identified the issue as "classism" and noted there is
no uniformity across the annual conferences in requirements to be
ordained a full member. Every annual conference can add to the
requirements that are in the Discipline.
Jurisdictional gatherings on Hispanic/Latino leadership are planned in
2008 and early 2009, culminating in a national conference in the fall of
*Green is a United Methodist News Service news writer based in Nashville, Tenn.
News media contact: Linda Green, (615) 742-5470 or firstname.lastname@example.org.
Costa Rica partnership to train Hispanic ministers
Urban ministry survey cites need for training, support
National Plan for Hispanic/Latino Ministry
United Methodist Board of Higher Education and Ministry
Course of Study
Is God Calling You
Steps Into Ordained Ministry
Ministry Study Report