|Church economic advisers assess recession's impact|
United Methodist investments lost significant value in 2008,
and church finance leaders say giving by individual congregations is
uncertain due to the
stock market's decline and weakness in the financial sector.
A UMNS photo by John Goodwin.
Dec. 12, 2008 | NASHVILLE, Tenn. (UMNS)
The United Methodist Church faces significant challenges in 2009
under a U.S. recession, but financial leaders project a recovery to
begin in the latter months of the new year.
An economic advisory committee of the denomination's finance
agency—made up of economists, financial analysts, researchers and church
leaders—gathered Dec. 5 in Nashville to assess the church's financial
"Each recession is unique, so predicting the duration of the current
recession is inherently difficult," said Don House, an economist and
committee member from College Station, Texas.
"We have a better understanding of what policy measures are required at
the federal level, and we believe there is a clear intention among
policymakers to implement effective measures."
"Each recession is unique," says
economist Don House.
A UMNS file photo by Marta W. Aldrich.
Church investments have lost significant value, and finance leaders
say giving by individual congregations is uncertain due to the stock
market's decline and weakness in the financial sector. However, they
note that the church has faced recessions before.
"We are all concerned about the financial future of our local
churches and our denomination as a whole," the General Council on
Finance and Administration said in a statement issued on Dec. 9.
"Although this time will not be easy for many, and will be very
difficult for some, the assembled experts anticipate an economic
recovery beginning in the latter months of 2009."
Before the stock markets became volatile at the close of September,
United Methodist giving for 2008 had been generally on target. Finance
leaders were hopeful but less sure about giving for the final months of
the year, when local churches, regional conferences and the general
denomination typically receive 40 percent of their annual income.
The denomination's $642 million budget for the next four-year
period—approved by General Conference last spring before the economy
began its downward spiral—is scheduled to take effect Jan. 1. Church
leaders have said they are prepared to make adjustments, if necessary.
"GCFA is constantly monitoring all economic indicators," said Bishop Lindsey Davis, president of the council.
"Indicators show us that the current connectional giving is still
strong through 2008. (The) 2009 (year) will present significant
challenges, but our boards and agencies are prepared to make any
necessary adjustments. Our thanks to the faithful members of The United
Methodist Church who continue to give generously even during these
In the United States, giving at the local church level tends to
decline during recessions when adjusted for inflation, and then increase
in the years following, according to information provided by GCFA.
During the recession of the late 1970s and early 1980s, giving
dropped 2.43 percent from 1978 to 1979, then declined another 3.11
percent in 1980, and another 0.31 percent in 1981. Giving then increased
an average of about 1.9 percent through 1989.
During the recession of the early 1990s, giving dropped about 1
percent in 1990, then increased an average of 2.12 percent over the next
12 years. Following the recession of the early 2000s, giving leveled
off again but began increasing again in 2003. Over the last 30 years,
local church giving has increased an average of 1.28 percent, adjusted
Nevertheless, the committee expects modest shortfalls in payments to the
general funds apportionment in 2008 and 2009, similar to those
experienced during past recessions.
Treasurer Moses Kumar and Bishop Lindsey Davis lead the GCFA board
meeting in November in St. Louis.
A UMNS photo by Marta W. Aldrich.
"Hope is always a primary focus for persons of faith in times of
crisis," said Moses Kumar, chief executive and treasurer of GCFA. "Our
pulpits and pews are filled every Sunday with messages to maintain hope
during a time that is seeing the greatest volatility in the U.S. markets
in recent decades."
The denomination's 2009-12 budget was built around the four areas
identified by church leaders as priorities: engaging in ministry with
the poor; stamping out the diseases of poverty by improving health
globally; starting new churches and renewing existing ones; and
developing principled Christian leaders.
"We must look with a theological eye toward the use of all of our
resources, letting both our visions for ministry and the example of
Jesus' mission—of bringing good news to the poor, letting the oppressed
go free, and proclaiming Jubilee—shape the use of our resources," said
the Rev. Dustin Petz, pastor of Goodland (Kan.) United Methodist Church
and a member of the committee.
"This will mean we will have to be more strategic with the employment
of our time, our finances and our energy. Making these changes will be
difficult, but we now have an opportunity to see the current context as a
chance to be more effective at making disciples for Jesus Christ and
transforming the world."
*This story was based in part of a news release and a statement by
the United Methodist General Council on Finance and Administration.
News media contact: Marta Aldrich, Nashville, Tenn., (615) 742-5470 or firstname.lastname@example.org.
Economy's effect on church giving, budgets uncertain
United Methodists call for stewardship over greed
United Methodist pension board focuses on long term during down market
Commentary: John Wesley's advice on the economy
Assembly approves $642 million churchwide budget
Changing demographics affecting church funding
General Council on Finance and Administration
Board of Pension and Health Benefits
United Methodist Church Foundation
Social Principles: The Economic Community