Home > Our World > News > News Archives by Date > 2012 > February 2012 > News - February 2012
John Wesley and black colleges

 
Translate

 



Teacher and students at Philander Smith are engaged in a discussion of math. Photos courtesy of Philander Smith College.
Teacher and students at Philander Smith are engaged in a discussion of math. Photos courtesy of Philander Smith College.
View in Photo Gallery

1:00 P.M. ET February 17, 2012

One of the most important historical stories is the work of the Methodist Church in establishing education for newly freed slaves. This work was consistent with the work of John Wesley, who actively fought against slavery.

President Lincoln established the Freedmen’s Bureau in 1865 to assist newly freed slaves with food, housing, education and employment, and the Methodist Episcopal Church established the Freedmen’s Aid Society the next year.

The Board of Bishops of the church made an awesome declaration at a New York meeting in November of 1866. They wrote:

The emancipation of four millions of slaves has opened at our very doors a wide field calling, alike for mission and educational work .… The time may come when the States in the South will make some provision for the education of the colored children now growing up in utter ignorance in their midst. But thus far they have made none, nor perhaps can it soon be expected of them. Christian philanthropy must supply this lack. We cannot turn away from the appeal that comes home to our consciences and hearts. Nor can we delay. The emergency is upon us, and we must begin to work now.

This declaration led to the founding of our historically Black colleges and universities (HBCUs). Today, there are 11 of those institutions that remain. They are supported in part by the Black College Fund of The United Methodist Church.

United Methodist model system



Dr. Walter Kimbrough, president of Philander Smith College.
Dr. Walter Kimbrough, president of Philander Smith College.
View in Photo Gallery

The United Methodist Church, the first mainline denomination to articulate social principles, actualizes its social gospel through a variety of means, including HBCUs. Of the various denominations and religious groups that organized HBCUs after slavery, it is widely acknowledged that The United Methodist Church has the model system for support.

And yet, many wonder if the time for these institutions has passed, and that the church, suffering from a slow decline, may need to use its resources in other ways. Many rightfully note that America is different from the America of 1866 when the bishops saw the health, education and welfare of Blacks as an emergency. Some note the advances in education, an increasing number of Black billionaires, and the extraordinary successes of national leaders including former Secretaries of State Condoleeza Rice and Colin Powell, and of course, President Barack Obama.

But, even as we near the 150th anniversary of the end of slavery, an emergency still exists. Michelle Alexander, a law professor at the Moritz College of Law at The Ohio State University, methodically documents in her book “The New Jim Crow,” a criminal justice system that has targeted men of color under the guise of a colorblind society.

She cites studies indicating that people use and sell drugs at similar rates regardless of race, but the sentences for Black men are 20 to 50 times greater than those for White men, which has created a Black prison population in the United States today greater in proportion than South Africa during the height of apartheid.

A study by Thomas Shapiro, author of “The Hidden Cost of Being African American” and a professor at the Heller School for Social Policy and Management at Brandeis University, noted, “Even when African-Americans do everything right — get an education and work hard at well-paying jobs — they cannot achieve the wealth of their White peers in the workforce.”

By 2007, White median wealth was $100,000. It was $5,000 for Blacks. With Black unemployment double that of Whites for more than 30 years, the wealth gap continues to grow.



Students work on computers in the library at Philander Smith College.
Students work on computers in the library at Philander Smith College.
View in Photo Gallery

Church institutions poised to lead

The church is blessed to have a set of institutions poised to take the lead in addressing these modern-day emergencies. And, this is empowering for students that have lived these injustices. Disproportionately, they have known the new Jim Crow through friends and relatives, and with 70 percent of United Methodist HBCU students low-income — versus only 21 percent at other United Methodist schools — this “hidden cost” presents challenges when trying to earn a degree.

HBCUs live out a social gospel by educating their students and preparing them to solve these issues. Wiley College hosts an annual ethical student leadership conference that strengthens student values. Claflin University’s mission is preparing visionary leaders for global challenges. Dillard University partnered with the National Institutes of Health to study and correct health-care disparities. Bennett College for Women launched a global studies and entrepreneurship program. Similar programs exist at Huston-Tillotson, Paine, Rust, Bethune-Cookman and Meharry Medical College. And, of course, at Philander Smith College we changed our mission to focus on social justice.

United Methodist HBCUs live the call of John Wesley who, according to George Fox University professor of church history and theology Irv Brendlinger, “had no tolerance for the kind of Christianity that was egocentrically occupied with one’s own spiritual state, and, therefore, blind to the human needs nearby.”

Our HBCUs ensure that we focus on issues at home and are working to continue the legacy of the church by living our social principles. They represent our social principles in action.

*Kimbrough is president of Philander Smith College in Little Rock, Ark. On July 1, he will become the seventh president of Dillard University in New Orleans.

News media contact: Heather Hahn, Nashville, Tenn., (615) 742-5470 or newsdesk@umcom.org.

Commenting Rules

Comments will not appear until approved by a moderator, which will occur at least twice daily.

Please keep your comments brief. Avoid personal attacks and do not use inflammatory or demeaning language.

See our Comment Policy for more information.

Glad you liked it. Would you like to share?

Sharing this page …

Thanks! Close

Add New Comment

  • Image

Showing 17 comments

  • William Payne 3 comments collapsed Collapse Expand

    We should promote the welfare of all people as we acknowledge the disparities in society. Still, on the basis of scripture, I question a church based approach that singles people out on the basis of skin color. Poverty and disadvantage is not bound to any ethnic enclave. From Appalachia, to Los Angeles, to Mississippi, to Chicago, Americans and undocumented aliens of all colors need help. It is time that we moved beyond categories of past generations and seek an inclusive model that does not elevate one population of poor above another. Plus, why do we need to segregate Black...

    show more
  • Walter M. Kimbrough 2 comments collapsed Collapse Expand

    Thanks for your thoughts Williams. Let me provide some food for thought.

    This country singles out people of color every day, notably to penalize them. Even in a colorblind justice system, we see disproportionate numbers of Black and brown men being prosecuted, labeled felons, and forever second class citizens. Hendrix College graduate Douglas Blackmon shows this well in his powerful text, "Slavery by Another Name: The Re-Enslavement of Black Americans from the Civil War to World War II." So first slavery, then slavery by another name, and today, the new Jim Crow- all singling out people based on...

    show more
  • William Payne 1 comment collapsed Collapse Expand

     Dr. Kimbrough, you did not address the essence of my questions. The mere fact that they are called Black colleges is a problem.

    show more show less
  • Walter M. Kimbrough 8 comments collapsed Collapse Expand

    Creed you have to look at the demographics. The United Methodist Church is less than 5% African American. Plus, I think our mission is to reach people and not simply serve Methodists (which is what Irv Bredlinger's book talks about).

    Only 25% is a lot when there are 103 HBCUs and over 4,000 colleges and universities. This sector serves more African American students than any other.

    By supporting the HBCUs you do exactly as you suggest- help students with need who are the first in their families to attend college. Without the HBCUS, Methodist higher education instutions...

    show more
  • Creed Pogue 7 comments collapsed Collapse Expand

    If only 25% of African-American college students are at ANY of the HBCUs, then 75% of them are not.  My concern isn't really a question of need.  There are many, many needs that should draw our dollars.  But, we are putting these eleven schools above virtually everything else because they are a "designated outreach fund" and part of the general church apportionment structure.  In our conferences are many students (especially in these difficult economic times amid tuition hikes and aid reductions) who need help paying for college.  Would we really say that all of the students at those eleven...

    show more
  • Walter M. Kimbrough 6 comments collapsed Collapse Expand

    There are about 25,800 African Americans enrolled in the roughly 90 UMC undergraduate schools. 12,700 of them attend the 10 HBCUs. Without these schools the church would serve few African American students. So if 10 schools enroll almost 50% of African Americans in UMC higher education, you can't deny that's signficant.

    I agree that you couldn't say that all are more deserving. But more than twice as many count as low income, so the greater majority of these students have need as defined by the Pell Grant. In addition, the UMC HBCUs cost about HALF as the other...

    show more

    (Edited by a moderator)

  • William Payne 2 comments collapsed Collapse Expand

    Dr. Kimbrough, if we want to pursue MLK Jr's dream and the ideal of
    Pentecost, we should push for an inclusive educational environment in which all of
    God's people study together as they learn to be the people of God. How
    does the present arrangement move us toward the kingdom vision that we
    find in the NT? Interestingly, many UM leaders have lamented that Sunday
    morning is the most segregated hour in the week. At the same time we
    encourage segregation when we push for Black colleges. The racist
    aspects of American society will never be erased as long...

    show more
  • Walter M. Kimbrough 1 comment collapsed Collapse Expand

    The question really is has the present arrangement prevented the church from inclusion every Sunday morning as you lamented? No. Why? Because the fact is that worship is cultural. As a UMC preacher's kid I have been to all kinds of churches. There is a distinctive white church and a black church. Service times vary in length. Musical styles are very different. Preaching and congregational response a diametrically opposite. So that's a barrier. Just being honest, I won't join a church where I am not culturally connected. I'm comfortable with the Hammond organ riffs, contemporary Gospel being sung by...

    show more
  • Creed Pogue 3 comments collapsed Collapse Expand

    I respect Dr. Kimbrough's institutional interest.  But, we need to start asking the important questions about priorities.  Are there even 4,000 United Methodists who are attending the eleven UMC-supported HBCUs?  At $9.5 million, that means at least $2,375 per UM.  Imagine the strong sense of accomplishment if our conferences were providing even $1,000 for students who were the first in their family to attend college?

    show more show less
  • Creed Pogue 1 comment collapsed Collapse Expand

    We are providing a special place for support of certain schools connected with the United Methodist Church.  Why?  Not all of the students have exceptional need.  But, we don't have a special fund in our apportionments for students attending other UMC-connected schools who have exceptional need.  Is that fair or reasonable?

    As bad as some of the socio-economic statistics are for states like Mississippi, Arkansas or Louisiana, no one would want to substitute the situation in Zimbabwe for them.  So, it is hard to make a serious comparison between Africa University and the Black College Fund on those...

    show more
  • Walter M. Kimbrough 1 comment collapsed Collapse Expand

    I agree- and it is a major, philosophical question. So, why is it important now for the United Methodist Church to only provide education for United Methodists? When the HBCUs were started the students weren't Methodist. African Americans couldn't even worship as equals which led to the creation of the African Methodist Episcopal Church (AME).

    You get that sense of accomplishment you write about now with the HBCUs since those students have more need than students who attend other UMC schools. Black College fund schools have many more first generation, low income students. And because the cost is lower, you...

    show more
  • Creed Pogue 3 comments collapsed Collapse Expand

    Only one school of the eleven has a student body that is even 40% United Methodist.  The rest are 10% or less.  Only 25% of all African-American college students attend any HBCU.  Perhaps the time has come to eliminate the Black College Fund and instead encourage annual conferences to have scholarships to help students who would be the first in their family to attend college.  That would do more for upward social mobility.

    show more show less
  • UMNS editor 2 comments collapsed Collapse Expand

    Creed, please know that even students who are not United Methodist when they enter a United Methodist-supported HBCU or other United Methodist campus often become United Methodist while there and remain so after graduation. I don't have hard data across the board, but while I lived and worked in Arkansas, I met dozens of Philander Smith and Hendrix students and alumni who were not cradle United Methodists but were drawn to campus ministry and have been United Methodist ever since. Colleges, among their many other benefits, also give the church an evangelism tool.

    show more show less
  • Creed Pogue 1 comment collapsed Collapse Expand

    Hoping for future membership gains is a different reason than trying to address a past injustice or provide opportunities today.  When that is put forward as a reason, it then begs the question of whether that is the most productive use for dollars to bring younger people to Christ and whether annual conferences who may see very few students going to those 11 schools should be asked as an apportionment to fund it instead of an Advance special.

    show more show less
  • Walter M. Kimbrough 1 comment collapsed Collapse Expand

    Which statement? You didn't specify.

    Walter Kimbrough

    show more show less
  • Walter M. Kimbrough 1 comment collapsed Collapse Expand

    Which statement Rev. Facemyer?

    Walter Kimbrough

    show more show less
  • Danieldfacemyer 1 comment collapsed Collapse Expand

    after learning through Church History, the commendable history of the Menonite and Quaker Christians responding to the social ills of society, both in Europe and USA, I find the statement by Dr. Kimbrough to highly offensive. Offensive because it places United Methodists' in a line of arrogance that does run opposed to the teaching of John Wesley. As a retired UM clergy I hope that Dr. Kimbrough was misquoted.
    Daniel D Facemyer

    show more show less

Ask Now

This will not reach a local church, district or conference office. InfoServ* staff will answer your question, or direct it to someone who can provide information and/or resources.

Phone
(optional)

*InfoServ ( about ) is a ministry of United Methodist Communications located in Nashville, Tennessee, USA. 1-800-251-8140

Not receiving a reply?
Your Spam Blocker might not recognize our email address. Add this address to your list of approved senders.

Would you like to ask any questions about this story?ASK US NOW