Rev. Dan R. DickCommentary: Real Jesus is bigger than any movie depiction

By Rev. Dan R. Dick

Actor Jim Caviezel joins elite company by portraying Jesus Christ in Mel Gibson’s "The Passion of the Christ."

The canonized gospel story - written in many different forms between the early second century and the late 1960s - is cinematic in its raw form. As director Cecil B. DeMille once claimed, it "cries out to be filmed." For 80 years, a handful of men have been chosen to represent Jesus in movies and on TV, all to mixed critical review.

What does it take to be Jesus, even if only in a movie? Many actors claim that the honor is both humbling and life changing, while others see it as just another role. Regardless of the opinion of the actors, viewers tend to hold high standards against which any portrayal of the Son of God is measured.

Many people who came of age in the ’60s still remember the performances of Max von Sydow ("The Greatest Story Ever Told") and Jeffrey Hunter ("King of Kings") as the very definition of the role.
Many people who came of age in the ’60s still remember the performances of Max von Sydow ("The Greatest Story Ever Told") and Jeffrey Hunter ("King of Kings") as the very definition of the role. Both men gave deeply respectful performances that helped imprint visual images of the life and death of Jesus in the minds of millions.

A decade later, two very different portrayals of Jesus resulted in controversy and conflict. Jesus was a face-painted jester in a Superman T-shirt in "Godspell," an off-Broadway play that moved to the silver screen in 1973 with Victor Garber as the whimsical Christ. By the time the movie was made (two years after the play), much of the controversy had quieted. Still, many people were offended by the less-than-holy presentation of God’s son.

Much more troubling to many more people - both on stage and screen - was "Jesus Christ Superstar." In the movie, screeching, bawling Ted Neeley offered the most extreme Jesus to date. Written as a rock opera without pretensions to proselytizing, "Superstar" opened to picket lines and inflammatory sermons worldwide. Neeley’s shrill, emotional, down-to-earth rebel Jesus offended many Christians. In truth, both Neeley and Garber opened millions of young people to a more real, more accessible Jesus.

Television gave the world one of the most memorable - and without argument the prettiest - portrayals when Robert Powell assumed the role. Powell’s angular figures and deep blue eyes most closely evoked the famous "Head of Christ" painting by Warner Sallman. This mini-series garnered widespread approval for its images of Jesus, though it was criticized for the license taken with the gospel story.

Perhaps the most controversial screen Jesus ever appeared in the person of Willem Dafoe in 1988’s "The Last Temptation of Christ." Based on Nikos Kazantzakis’ novel rather that the canonized gospels of the New Testament, this film deeply enraged conservative Christians worldwide. Thousands of people took to the streets to protest a Jesus with human emotions, desires and psychological weaknesses. Kazantzakis intended to present the loneliness and deep anxiety and pain that might have been felt by the human Jesus as he wrestled with the mantle of the Christ.

"The Passion of the Christ" opens to both rave reviews from Christians across the theological spectrum and deep controversy from Jewish leaders concerned with the strong anti-Semitic inferences of the film. Some university and seminary professors are concerned with the narrow theology and the liberties taken with the story. Other concerns deal with the graphic and violent nature of the movie, as well as with the commercialization of the Christian faith.

Caviezel presents a deeply moving, real, and powerful Jesus - so powerful, in fact, that a whole generation will think of him when they picture Jesus in their mind.
However, taken on the merits of the film itself and specifically focusing on the portrayal of Jesus by Jim Caviezel, there is little disagreement. Caviezel presents a deeply moving, real, and powerful Jesus - so powerful, in fact, that a whole generation will think of him when they picture Jesus in their mind.

The most recent portrayal of Jesus may forever alter the way actors approach the role. There is not much characterization in "The Passion of the Christ." Jesus is an object - abused, sadistically beaten, torn and humiliated. The humanity of the man Jesus is obliterated, while glimpses of the divine are allowed through briefly.

Jesus is a victim in "The Passion" to such an extent that the greater message gets lost. There is little to celebrate of the one who conquered death and atoned for the sins of all. In earlier versions of the story the message of Jesus teachings, the power of his healing, and the glory of the resurrection balanced the horror of the crucifixion.

Movies communicate with power visual images that stay with us all our lives. We may endlessly debate the best screen Jesus, but almost every Christian has a nominee to defend. The challenge to each of us is to remember that the real Jesus is larger and more complex than any image - graven or celluloid. Actors who portray the Christ point not to themselves, but beyond themselves. The story they enact is a grand and glorious story, but it is much greater than the messenger, especially human messengers portraying Jesus the Christ.

Every screen representation of the gospel story is incomplete - some terribly incomplete, like "The Passion of the Christ" - and should challenge us to dig deeper. May these films and all the portrayals of Jesus that they contain be for us an invitation - an invitation to meet Jesus in prayer, in Scripture, and in a community of faith that enables us to meet the Christ in others.

Dick is research manager for the New Solutions Team at the United Methodist Board of Discipleship in Nashville, Tenn.

Online Discussion


Contact Us

This will not reach a local church, district or conference office. InfoServ* staff will answer your question, or direct it to someone who can provide information and/or resources.

Phone
(optional)

*InfoServ ( about ) is a ministry of United Methodist Communications located in Nashville, Tennessee, USA. 1-800-251-8140

Not receiving a reply?
Your Spam Blocker might not recognize our email address. Add InfoServ@umcom.org to your list of approved senders.