This translation is not completely accurate as it was automatically generated by a computer.
Powered by
A UMNS Commentary
By Erin Hawkins*
1:00 P.M. EDT April 12, 2011
Erin Hawkins addresses the United
Methodist Church Leadership
Summit webcast in Nashville, Tenn.
A UMNS photo by Mike DuBose.
View in Photo Gallery
As a presenter at the Leadership Summit on April 6, and as a church
leader who has been involved in many conversations about change in the
denomination, I have been reflecting on this time in our life as a
community of faith with great anticipation and even greater prayer.
Many friends old and new have sent me words of encouragement and
challenge about what was discussed and what was noticeably absent during
the summit webcast. My experience then — and the many conversations I’ve had since — has led me to share what I left unsaid that day.
I was asked a question about overcoming our racial divisions in the
church that led me to a more general reflection on diversity and
inclusion. As I spoke, these words were written on my mental
teleprompter: “We must continue to have open and honest discussions
about sexual orientation in the church — conversations that lead to
peace and unity, not contempt and division.”
I got to the place where I could practically feel the words on my
lips and stopped. I struggled for several minutes with whether or not to
speak up, and sadly, I let the moment pass.
I must admit, I was afraid. I feared that raising this often
emotionally charged issue would somehow derail the conversation and
undermine this attempt to initiate worldwide conversation on mission and
ministry effectiveness. I was afraid of a whole host of things that
often confront those who have professed to follow the way of Christ.
My choice to remain silent — however well reasoned in the moment —
did not sit well with me. While I am not one given to absolutes when it
comes to judging right or wrong, in my heart I know my silence was
wrong.
Why do I confess my sin of omission?
1. Metrics and financial sustainability are not the only things we need to talk about. Let me be clear, I unapologetically support the position that our current practices as a church are financially unsustainable
and that we need more vigorous and comprehensive ways to assess and
communicate our impact in every community that we serve. This requires a
dramatic reorientation to the way that we “be and do church.”
That being said, sustainability and mission and
ministry effectiveness are inextricably tied to our capacity to love our
neighbor, to bring about justice in the world and to be willing to
engage the tough questions that people within and outside our faith
community deal with every day.
To not at least mention sexual orientation is to
deny that it is a real and present tension within our church. It also
reinforces our tendency as a denomination to skirt around or to be slow
in addressing issues of inclusion. How sustainable is a church whose
leaders don’t create opportunities to name the justice challenges it
faces? A vital (healthy) church engages with boldness and humility the
issues of racism, sexism, homophobia, war, poverty and hunger.
2. Effective leadership is a driver of vitality. The Call to Action report
clearly names clergy and lay leadership as a driver of church vitality.
Integrity is essential to effective leadership. During the webcast, I
called for our leaders to exhibit courage and grace in the face of the
“isms.” Many agreed with me. If we are to be part of a renewed, relevant
and vital church, we must to the best of our ability — and with God’s
help and saving grace — exhibit these qualities as well. I failed that
day but am thankful for a God of second chances.
3. God has a vision for the church. Our
brothers and sisters in the Democratic Republic of the Congo asked this
deeply profound question during the summit: “What is God’s vision for
the church?”
In Matthew 19:21, Jesus admonishes a rich young man
seeking his own form of sustainability to “sell everything you own and
give to the poor… then come follow me.” I believe that God is shouting
to us from the highest heavens, “Get rid of it! All of it!” We must get
rid of our attachment to oversized and costly buildings that sit in
mockery of the almost nonexistent ministry happening. We must get rid of
our dependence on old methods, policies, structures and viewpoints that
no longer prove useful or just.
And when we have gotten rid of everything that
stands in the way of our being God’s hands, feet and heart in the world,
we will be free to give lavishly of our love, passion, commitment and
service to the poor, brokenhearted, sick, excluded, abused and
marginalized. Then and only then will we be a church that truly makes
disciples of Jesus Christ for the transformation of the world.
Conversations about the future of The United Methodist Church are far
from over. There will be many more opportunities for all of us to make
our voices heard. My hope is that no matter what our beliefs are, we
will choose to do so.
Paul’s prayer for the church in Philippi is my prayer for all of us
during this time, that our love will grow more and more; that we will
have knowledge and understanding with our love; that we will see the
difference between good and bad and will choose the good; that we will
be pure and without wrong for the coming of Christ; that we will be
filled with the good things produced in our life by Christ to bring
glory and praise to God.
*Hawkins is the top staff executive of the United Methodist Commission on Religion and Race.
News media contact: Tim Tanton, Nashville, Tenn., 615-742-5470 or newsdesk@umcom.org.
About UMC.org
RSS Feed
Press Center
Contact Us