This translation is not completely accurate as it was automatically generated by a computer.
Powered by
A UMNS Commentary
By the Rev. Michael E. Williams*
7:00 A.M. EST February 1, 2011
A web-only illustration from MaryLB / iStockphoto.
Whenever a tragedy like the recent shootings in Tucson, Ariz.,
occurs, commentators are tempted to play the “evil” card. Either the
specific act or the person who performed the deed is defined as evil.
It’s probably human nature for us to place any act of violence or
destruction in a category. Doing so helps us feel that we can
comprehend how something like this could happen. That person is “evil,”
therefore different from us, and this act is “evil,” therefore
something we would never do. We feel a little better about our
worldview and ourselves.
Often we move from calling a specific action or person “evil” to
describing entire groups of people that way. Countries or groups we see
as our enemies get the label “evil” attached to them, and we make up
derogatory names to call them. Once we rob them of their humanity, we
are justified in harming them. Once again, we have framed the world so
that we feel better about our group and ourselves, because, of course,
we are not like them. They are evil.
While such reactions may be comforting, they do not represent an
adequate understanding of the nature of human beings or the nature of
evil. John Wesley examined the issue of good and evil, and provided us
with some assistance. Wesley’s General Rules have become popular in
recent years. Bishop Reuben Job and others have described them as
“Three Simple Rules.”
The first of those was abridged to read, “Do no harm,” but Wesley
added to that “by avoiding evil of every kind.” For Wesley, evil was
something to be avoided, if we are intent on doing no harm to others and
ourselves. Wesley identified “evil” not as a person, group or deed but
suggested that it is the capacity we all have to do harm.
The Rev. Michael Williams preaches at West End United Methodist Church
in Nashville, Tenn., where he serves as senior pastor. A UMNS photo
courtesy of Michael Williams.
View in photo gallery
The second of Mr. Wesley’s rules involved “doing good of every
possible sort, and, as far as possible, to all.” Here again good, like
evil, is a capacity that all human beings share. Both good and evil are
inclinations of every human heart. We are to follow the inclination to
do good to all and harm to none.
The line between good and evil does not fall between people or
groups but rather right down the middle of the human heart. For Wesley,
the possibility of doing good or harm resulted from the free will God
gives us to choose to follow one inclination over another. In truth,
much evil is not dramatic.
In 1963, Hannah Arendt published a book about the trial of Adolf
Eichmann. The subtitle is “The Banality of Evil.” Her warning is that,
too often, following the evil inclination of the human heart is so
commonplace that we don’t even see our participation in it as doing
harm. Eichmann - a Nazi who was hanged for his role in the Holocaust -
was an administrator in an office, a loyal worker who did as he was
instructed to do.
Even today, someone signs a document, and half a world away people
are killed. Someone lets a regulation slide, and the building that was
supposed to withstand an earthquake or flood doesn’t. Food that was
supposed to be safe makes those who eat it sick, or the pension that
was supposed to be there isn’t. We purchase a particular shirt or pair
of shoes, and children sold into slavery continue to work in unsafe
conditions in factories on the other side of the globe.
It may have been our commonplace participation in evil that moved
Jesus to warn his followers to take the log out of their own eye before
attempting to remove the speck from their neighbor’s eye. Before we
start attaching the word “evil” to others, we might want to take a
good, hard look at ourselves.
*Williams is senior pastor of West End United Methodist Church, Nashville, Tenn.
News media contact: Barbara Dunlap-Berg, Nashville, Tenn., (615) 742-5489 or newsdesk@umcom.org.
About UMC.org
RSS Feed
Press Center
Contact Us